Bone Broth: Why is this simmering bowl of soup called the “Jewish Penicillin”

bone broth cooking

Last Updated October 11th, 2019

What is bone broth?

Bone broth – sounds savage – straight out of the ancient times when the man was a hunter-gatherer. In reality, nothing savage about this plain hot liquid. Known for being full of nutrition, in certain cultures, it is still an integral part of daily food. Throughout history, there is proof in most cultures that in some of the other form, serving bone broth was a tradition.

Despite the presence of different kinds of supplements and artificial ways of replacing essential elements and deficiencies in our body, bone broth has in the last couple of years gained sudden popularity. So much so that there is a so-called bone broth craze going on. In 2015, long queues of people, during lunch hours, were seen outside New York restaurants serving different flavored broths.

bone broth bonesThis sudden popularity, however, doesn’t have anything to do with the newly discovered, life-enhancing effect of bone broth. Other than, how this hot liquid feels inside on a cold day, no new revelations have yet been made. It has been projected by Global Market Insights, Inc that by 2024, the global Broth market will be more than USD 2.8 billion by 2024.

Very little has ever been documented scientifically in terms of how bone broth helps our overall health. On top of that, there is no documented recipe with specific instructions to make a bone broth. Most cultures believe that bone broths are supposed to be simmered for many hours for the nutrition from the bones to dissolve into the liquid but there are varied cooking times for different broths.

Popular beliefs

The feel-good image of broth or soup may have contributed to creating certain concepts and perceptions about what it is good for without much substantial proof. Right from weight loss to brighter skin to better bones – people have been attributing this concoction to sorts of goodness. Some believe that because there is a lot of collagen in bone broths, which is the binding element for the body, it increases the amount of collagen in our body. Bone broth champions believe it helps with joint pains, stomach inflammation, and even insomnia.

Composition and Benefits

Based on popular belief and what dieticians all over the world are saying, bone broths have a very rich composition in terms of vitamins and essential elements.

  • Animal bones, knuckles, marrow, skin, connecting tissues when boiled down to broth vitamins like phosphorous, magnesium, calcium are released from them. These minerals are essential in maintaining bone density and formation of new bone.
  • Fish broth contains iodine which is essential to prevent thyroid related dysfunction and healthy metabolism.
  • It contains omega 3 and omega 6 fatty acids which store a lot of energy.
  • It is believed to be helpful in the digestive process. First of all, bone broth in itself is easy to digest. It has gelatin which binds itself to liquids in our digestive system helping food to move smoothly. Gelatin also secretes an amino acid called glutamine which helps in better functioning of intestines.
  • A lot of women in today’s age suffer from degenerative bone problems at a very young age. Collagen which is one of the revered ingredients in bone broth is known for supporting joint health. Amino acids like proline and glycine which are present in connecting tissues are produced when collagen is broken down.
  • Glucosamine and chondroitin are found in animal cartilage which joins our bones. These compounds are also present in bone broth.
  • It potentially can help in weight loss as it is rich with essential elements and does not release too many calories. A lot of vegetables that are not very popular can be consumed in a broth. Broth can fill you up and satiate your hunger without consumption of a lot of heavy foods. Because water is the main ingredient of the broth, most of it passes through the digestive system without getting absorbed.
  • Glycine which is an amino acid is known to help with sleeplessness. A lot of people go through shallow or no sleep nights. Having bone broth can help in getting deeper and sounder sleep.
  • It is said that the amino acids in collagen which are present in connecting tissues and flesh help in toning up our skin. Skin becomes tighter reducing the lines of aging.

Broth Recipes

bone broth cookingThough there are no specific ways of making a broth, here are a few recipes to enjoy this hot, nutritious food:

Easy bone broth with veggies

Ingredients

2 chicken frames, without meat, about 3 pounds of chicken bones (or 1 turkey frame), Chicken feet (optional), 2 small onions ( peeled and cut into quarters), 2 medium carrots (peeled or scrubbed and cut into large chunks), 3 stalks celery (washed and cut into large chunks), 4 cloves garlic (peeled and smashed), 1 1-inch knob of ginger (washed and peel left on), 1 bay leaf, 6-10 peppercorns, 1 Tbsp. apple cider vinegar, 4 quarts filtered water, more or less, to fill the slow cooker crock

Instructions

  • Place bones and chicken feet, if using, into a large stock pot.
  • Add onions, carrots, celery, garlic, bay leaf and peppercorns.
  • Fill pot with enough filtered water to cover the bones.
  • Add apple cider vinegar (this helps leach minerals and collagen from the bones as it cooks and is a crucial ingredient).
  • Bring to a boil and skim the scum that rises to the top with a large spoon.
  • Reduce heat to LOW and simmer, covered, for 24 hours adding additional boiling water, if needed, to keep the bones submerged.
  • After 24 hours, remove from heat and allow the broth to cool slightly before straining through a fine-mesh strainer.
  • Broth may be stored in Mason jars with lids in the fridge for up to 5 days (remove a layer of hardened fat before use).

Quinoa and Vegetable Fall Stew

Ingredients

2 tablespoons olive oil, 1 yellow onion (chopped), 1 red bell pepper (stemmed, seeded and chopped), 4 large garlic cloves (minced), 1 tablespoon smoked paprika, 1/2 tablespoons ground cumin, 1/2 teaspoons ground coriander, 6 cups low sodium vegetable broth, 1 pound red potatoes cut into 1/2 inch pieces, 3/4 cup of prewashed quinoa, 1 cup frozen corn, 3 Roma tomatoes (cored and chopped), 1 cup frozen peas, juice of one lime, salt and pepper to taste.

Instructions:

  • In a large (4 quart), heavy-bottomed pot, heat oil over medium heat. Add onion and bell pepper and sauté until softened (about 7 minutes).
  • Add garlic, smoked paprika, cumin, and coriander and stir to coat vegetables. Add broth and potatoes and bring the liquid to a boil over high heat.
  • Reduce heat to medium-low after reaching a boil and gently simmer for about 12 minutes
  • Add quinoa and corn and cook until quinoa is tender (about 9 minutes).
  • Add tomatoes and peas. Remove from heat and season with salt, pepper and lime juice. Serve with optional ingredients for garnish.

In the earlier times, the whole point of a broth was to slowly infuse the goodness of bones, nutrients of vegetables into it. That is why it took more than 24 hours for a broth to be made. It also minimized wastage. But it is unthinkable that any household has the leisure of time to be able to cook something for more than an hour or simply cook anything. Bone broths are now available in the market in form of packaged powder. There are branded packaged broth available as well.

Skeptics say

bone broth healthyTwo years ago when this hype for broth was slowly rising, TIME magazine in the US published an article called “Science Can’t Explain Why Everyone is Drinking Bone Broth.” This article had a portion of William Percy’s commentary on how healthy bone broth is. Prof Percy is an Associate Professor with the University of South Dakota and works at the Sanford School of Medicine. When asked about the most revered component of bone broth he said, “Since we don’t absorb collagen whole, the idea that eating collagen somehow promotes bone growth is just wishful thinking. The idea that because bone broth or stock contains collagen it somehow translates to collagen in the human body is nonsensical. Collagen is actually a pretty poor source of amino acids.”

Dr. Kantha Shelke of the Institute of Food Technologists has stated that vegetables, especially green leafy vegetable are a much more prominent source of collagen.

Articles published on Harvardhealth website states:  A 1934 nutritional analysis in The Archives of Disease in Childhood concluded that bone broths are not of “great nutritional value.” There is no scientific evidence, however, to support many of the claims for any type of bone broth.

 

Supporters

Michal Ofer who is a wellness and digestion expert and nutrition coach writes in her blog “Properly prepared bone broths are extremely nutritious, containing the minerals and amino acids of all the superfoods: bone, cartilage, marrow, collagen, gelatin with the addition of vegetables as electrolytes – all in a form that is easy to assimilate. Because of its dense-nutritive properties and bioavailability, the benefits of bone broth are seemingly endless.”

bone broth healthy Michelle Gimbar who is the Director of Nutrition Services at Bridgewater Center for Nursing & Rehabilitation, Binghamton, New York wrote in the Journal of Renal Nutrition that this whole fascination with bone broth is because of the rising popularity of ‘Paleo Diet’. She states “Bone broth recipes can be found in popular “Paleolithic-based” cookbooks and is being touted as a way to relieve ailments from arthritis to wound healing. With this food trend gaining strength, you can find prepackaged bone broth next to customary broth products in your local grocery store.“

A study done in Taiwan and published in Food and Nutrition Research in 2017, concludes that though foods like bone broth or soup are good for health for their nutrient value. However, because of the inconsistency in bone tissue structure and mineral distribution, it is not possible to standardize a home remedy like this.

Be it general public, dieticians, celebrities or doctors, clearly bone broth and its benefits can’t be substantiated by anyone beyond doubt. Other than the fact that it feels good to have bone broth during a nasty cold or even when you are burning up, the fact that it has survived through ages and civilizations could be the testimony of its value for life.

Want to live a healthy lifestyle?

Subscribe to free FactDr newsletters.

REVAMP YOUR

If you're enjoying our website, we promise you'll absolutely love our new posts. Be the first one to get a copy!

Get factually correct, actionable tips delivered straight to your inbox once a week.

I want the latest scoop on :

We hate spam too. We will never share your email address with anyone. If you change your mind later, you can unsubscribe with just one click

By clicking Subscribe, I agree to the FactDr Terms & Conditions & Privacy Policy and understand that I may opt out of FactDr subscriptions at any time.

 

 

 

Related Posts

Trending Topics

anal sex
Anal Sex : Tips from experts on how to be kinky yet safe Whether it irks you or stokes your fantasies, anal sex has always been an intriguing…
Clitoris: Why is it called the gateway to toe-curling female orgasms? The word clitoris comes from the Greek word kleitoris or “little hill.”  Many compare the…
Female Masturbation: Tips on how to turn up the heat during a solo mission As a female, do you find yourself constantly wondering as to what is the best…
diverticulitis diet
Diverticulitis diet: The right way to eat if you suffer from the disease Are you suffering from diverticultis but clueless about your diet ? Read this complete plan…
Find the G spot: The top sex positions that guarantee an orgasm There has been a long debate as to whether the G-spot actually exists as a…
The science behind daith piercing: Can it really cure migraine? Since the ear has several pressure points, it is believed that daith piercing activates the…
Penis pump: Pump your way out of erectile dysfunction One of the options to treat erectile dysfunction is by the use of a penis…
Chromium Picolinate: An essential mineral supplement for faster weight loss Did you know that about 1.6 million deaths were directly linked to diabetes globally? How…
Quinine: How gin and tonic came to be known as a potent health elixir The discovery of quinine-containing tree bark is sometimes considered the most serendipitous medical discovery of…
hidden benefits walking
9 benefits of walking we bet you didn’t know! Did you know walking can be the miracle pill for eternal youth? Everyone knows walking…
eating disorder anorexia
Eating Disorders: Lifestyle choice or a psychological condition? Is eating disorder just a harmless bad habit? Or does it represent grim psychological disorders?…
passion fruit juice
Passion fruit: How one exotic fruit can help you fight infections and cancer! Passion fruit: Why does this exotic fruit have such an enticing name? And how can…
lifestyle diseases
The Big 5 lifestyle diseases: How your everyday living might be killing you You'd be shocked to know how unhealthy and potentially fatal your everyday routine could be.…
Muscle relaxers: Think twice before popping prescription drugs for muscle pain The market is brimming with OTC muscle relaxers. But these come with a host side-effects.…
How do neutrophils protect you from fatal bacterial attacks? During an infection, certain enzymes alert the mature neutrophils.  Neutrophils then travel through the bloodstream…
Top 6 remedies to treat a razor burn at home Symptoms of razor burn include bumps on the skin, redness, and irritation of the skin.…
stress depressed anxiety
Are you depressed or just stressed? Know when to see a doctor Why are some people more anxious than others? Is being depressed the same as feeling…
Maltitol: Things you must know about this artificial sweetener Sugar alcohols are produced by fruits and vegetables. Maltitol is an artificially produced sugar alcohol…
liver detox facts
7 liver detox facts and why ignoring these could kill you! Are you taking care of this organ that handles over 500 different vital functions in…
Vitamin-D-blood-test
25-Hydroxy Vitamin D test 25-hydroxy Vitamin D test is a blood test used to measure the level of vitamin…
occupational hazards types
Occupational Hazards: How to vouch for your health at your workplace Occupational hazards affect millions worldwide. Chemical spills, faulty wires, deadly pathogen, and work-stress can happen…
dance health benefits
5 unbelievable effects of dance on your overall health! You enjoy dancing, but did you know what else it does to your body? Dancing…
Tamarind: The top health benefits of this staple Asian ingredient Did you know this sweet and sour pulpy fruit does more than just add a…
What is the average penis size and why should you care? Scientifically speaking, the average size of the penis depends on numerous factors such as genes,…
Orgasms: How to perfect the art of achieving intense bursts of pleasure (every time!) Orgasms are dependent not just on the sexual activity but on your partner as well.…
yoga health benefits
How to practice yoga for astounding health benefits Can a 5000-year-old system be the ultimate body healer? Did you know yoga can make…
Milk Thistle skin
Milk Thistle: Find possible cures for fatal diseases in these purple blooms Milk thistle is well-known for treating liver conditions. However, did you know that it comes…
sleep deprivation
Don’t let your sleep deficit grow into memory loss or heart attack Why is sleep important for us? How could sleep deprivation harm you? We bet you…
Pumpkin Seeds: Why pumpkins are more than just for pies! Pumpkins have been long associated with Halloween carvings and delicious pies. But did you know…
Juice Plus: Can you really replace actual fruits with pills?  Juice Plus supplements intend to fill nutritional gaps present in our daily diet. But how…
CLA: A breakthrough weight loss supplement with minimal side effects Tried every weight loss supplement in the market with no substantial gain? Why not try…
Jicama: A fiber-rich tuber for your weight loss goals Pronouced as HEE-kah-ma, Jicama is the "new kid on the block" that has taken the…
autoimmune diseases facts
Autoimmune Diseases: Find out if your body is attacking you right now Did you know your body can harm itself? What are autoimmune diseases and why does…
Epley maneuver: Why is this the best protection from the symptoms of vertigo? Epley maneuver is an exercise that can treat the symptoms of benign paroxysmal positional vertigo…
low fodmap plan
Troubled with IBS? Here’s a complete roadmap to the low FODMAP diet Leaky & inflammatory gut troubling you? No medicine bringing you relief from the pain? Why…
Lectin: The common link of proteins between peas and people Lectins are a type of protein that are found majorly in legumes. Most people are…
Chondroitin spine health
9 amazing ways chondroitin can help you bounce back to health Chondroitin is naturally found in meat, especially in the connective tissues of animals. Chondroitin works…
social media adddiction
Your health in the age of Social Media: Why is digital detox a necessity? Did you know that more than 400 million people are dangerously addicted to social media?…
eating myths debunked
8 ‘healthy eating’ myths you believed until now Is a zero-carb diet really healthy for you? Are organic products worth their cost? Did…
Spirulina: Battle diabetes and cholesterol with this blue-green algae Spirulina, a species of salt water algae, has now become a billion dollar industry. How…
DASH Diet: What to eat in a “Dietary Approach to Stop Hypertension”? If you or your loved one is suffering from chronic hypertension (high blood pressure), dash…
Kava: Is it the healthy substitute for alcohol you have been waiting for? Native to the beautiful South Pacific islands, Kava is a famous beverage rooted in the…
about mediterranean diet
Why you should be adopting a Mediterranean style of diet today Ever wondered why the Mediterranean diet is so healthy? One simple solution to lowering risk…
L-theanine attention
L-Theanine: Better sleep, higher focus, and many other benefits Did you know that L-theanine found in green tea can make you sleep better and…
nutritional yeast bread
Nutritional Yeast : How can a fungi culture be good for your body? Nutritional yeast: How a simple culture of fungi can transform your skin, digestion, immunity ,…
Improve sex life
9 best tips from around the world for better sex life How can the pungent-smelling garlic pack in a punch to your libido? How could something…
Coconut sugar: What is it and is it healthier than table sugar? In the long list of things that the wonderful coconut gives us, coconut sugar is…
How can Kegels help you overcome weak pelvic muscles & incontinence? Kegel exercises are pelvic floor strengthening exercises that can help you overcome incontinence issues that…
waterchestnut
Water Chestnuts: The tastiest ways to include this healthy tuber in your diet Water chestnut is not a nut after all. It is a tuber (much like the…
Echocardiogram
Echocardiography – ECHO Echocardiography (commonly known as ECHO) is an imaging modality (similar to ultrasonography) used to visualize…
acne removal tips
Anatomy of acne: 7 instant steps to kiss those zits goodbye Blackheads, whiteheads, or pimples-call them what you may. Acne is never good news.Did you know…
boost immunity tips
Step up your defence: 15 proven tips on how to boost your immunity Want to naturally build up a stronger immunity? Tired of frequent colds and runny nose?You…
The real reason why you shouldn’t be eating ramen noodles Instant ramen noodles might be your go-to snack for your hunger pangs. But with each…
Chest X-Ray A chest x-ray is a diagnostic test that uses x-rays to visualize the structures inside…
chia seeds weight loss
Chia seeds: How to consume this staple Aztec food to get a leaner body Chia seeds: What is the actual reason for its sudden popularity? Why are celebrities swearing…
General adaptation syndrome: Understanding stress, one step at a time The struggle of the body to produce hormones during a stressful situation is the main…
These are the top foods to increase your hemoglobin count It is important to add iron-rich foods into your diet in order to increase hemoglobin. Deficiency…
nature health benefits
Green Healing: The amazing health benefits of being in nature You have no idea what sitting in a closed room does to your body and…
paleo keto diet
Paleo vs. Keto: Which diet plan is best suited for your body goals? Is eating like a caveman the right way to go? Can you really eat fats…
aspartame or sugar
Aspartame – Hidden truths about this storm in a teacup Aspartame, the artificial sweetener, has gone under the scanner on several occasions for allegedly doing…
vital organ diseases
Common diseases that could cripple your vital organs Brain, heart, kidney, lungs, and liver - these vital organs are indeed vital for your…
Anhedonia: Does the chronic inability to feel joy affect you too? How often do you feel dragged down by an invisible force? Do you feel an…
BRAT Diet: What is the right way to follow this diarrhea-relieving diet? BRAT diet, a simple diet consisting of just bananas, rice, applesauce, and toast, can help…
Goji berry: A traditional Chinese berry that packs the best of antioxidants Goji berry is an ancient berry that is considered to be power-packed with nutrients and…
hidden causes obesity
8 hidden causes of obesity you probably didn’t know! Did you know that around 2 billion people worldwide are either overweight or obese? Are…
dandelion health benefits
Dandelion: Little parachutes of health and wellness for your whole body Dandelions are not just bright looking blossoms that cheer your mind. These are powerpacked with…
Cordyceps: How the Caterpillar fungus works as a proven cancer-shield Strange as it may sound, but cordyceps or "caterpillar fungus", a fungus variety native to…
Astaxanthin: Why experts believe it could be 550x more potent than vitamin E! What is astaxanthin and why is this new supplement on the block touted as the…
Oxidative Stress: Understanding the most lethal phenomenon happening in your body right now Free radicals cause damage to the body, which is known as oxidation.  The amount of…
Top natural diuretics: The instant benefits you can get from nature’s water pills Since diuretic drugs are known to cause side effects, it is better to choose a…
tips for perfect sleep
Stop hitting the snooze button: 8 proven steps to perfect sleep Are you tired of not getting enough sleep? All your efforts for a sound sleep…
sugar toxic health
Sugar: 7 new shocking truths revealed about the sweet poison Can drinking soda bring you closer to death? Is sugar slowly poisoning you and your…
improve digestion weight loss
Power up your gut: 8 proven steps on how to improve your digestion Did you know you have a colony of bacteria in your gut that help you…
Psyllium Husk: More than just an effective natural laxative Psyllium husk, or isabgol, is a popular natural laxative . But did you in addition…
What is the right way to take a pregnancy test? A pregnancy test is undertaken to determine if you have conceived. A home pregnancy test…
Appendix pain: Recent findings on this not-so vestigial organ The exact function of the appendix is still not clear. Some consider it as an…
glucose-tolerance
Oral Glucose Tolerance Test – GTT Glucose tolerance test (or Oral GTT) is used to detect the onset of diabetes or…
cancer facts
8 hard-hitting truths no one tells you about cancer Did you know that 1.5 million new cases of cancer are reported every year? Can…
carrageenan seaweed
Carrageenan: How a simple seaweed extract could better your gut health & immunity Eat more ice cream to prevent cold and flu? –With carrageenan you get one simple…
quinoa salad
Quinoa : A prodigious superfood you need to include in your diet today! Quinoa - what is so special about this native South American grain that has taken…
Fluoride: An indispensible mineral or a potential toxin ? Fluoride, the main ingredient of toothpaste, has shown a great potential as a cleanser. However,…
Drinking water benefits
8 reasons why you should grab a bottle of water now! Did you know you don't have to be thirsty for hours to be dehydrated?You could…
xylitol gum
Xylitol : Is this the right sugar substitute for you? Discovered during World War 2 owing to sugar shortage, xylitol has become a common name…
TBHQ: A carcinogen lingering in your child’s favorite snacks TBHQ - Why you should shun the practice of eating instant noodles or microwave popcorn…
Exercises or diet? Find out the healthiest way to gain weight Tired of being called skinny all the time? Looking for healthy ways to beef up?…
dandelion weight loss
Caralluma Fimbriata: How to eat this cactus to lose weight Caralluma fimbriata is a miracle cactus that can be safely consumed by most for losing…
How can berberine supplements help you live longer and healthier? Berberine is a turmeric look-alike herbal extract that is credited with numerous health benefits ranging…
Pescatarian Diet 101: What are the inherent health advantages of this diet? People opt to become a pescatarian in order to enrich their bodies with the essential…
Mood swings
The real reasons for your mood swings and how to overcome them Are you prone to heated moods frequently? Do you also feel bouts of depressive feeling…
Vagus nerve: 7 health benefits of stimulating the “gut-brain” connection As a matter of fact, there are two vagus nerves namely the left and the…
Surgery or home-remedy; what is the right way to treat a burn The treatment of a burn injury depends on its severity. You can save a life…
Endoscopy Endoscopy is a procedure where an illuminated probe with a camera attached to it is…
dengue-test
Dengue NS1 test Dengue NS1 is a blood test used to determine the onset of dengue fever. Dengue…
High Fiber Diet – Fire up your fiber intake for these health benefits! Regular bowels, healthy detox, higher immunity, and guaranteed weight loss - a high fiber diet…
essential amino acids
Amino acids: Building blocks of life for better mood and sex drive! Find out why amino acids are often called as the building blocks of life. And…
MCT oil athletes
MCT Oil : The kind of fats you should be eating MCT oil or Medium Chain Triglycerides is the new buzzword in the fitness industry. What…
bananas exercise
10 health reasons why you should go “bananas” over bananas! Bananas:The world's most popular fruit comes with a host of unbelievable health benefits. Find out…
erectile dysfunction treatment
Erectile Dysfunction: Effective tips to help you get back on charge Erectile dysfunction is a common male sexual dysfunction. Don't stress out. Just follow these amazing…
Garlic health benefits cloves
Garlic: Nature’s white pill as an effective home remedy What are the secrets hidden in these tiny white pills? Find out the immense health…

Related Posts

Want to live a healthy lifestyle?

Subscribe to free FactDr newsletters.

REVAMP YOUR

If you're enjoying our website, we promise you'll absolutely love our new posts. Be the first one to get a copy!

Get factually correct, actionable tips delivered straight to your inbox once a week.

I want the latest scoop on :

We hate spam too. We will never share your email address with anyone. If you change your mind later, you can unsubscribe with just one click

By clicking Subscribe, I agree to the FactDr Terms & Conditions & Privacy Policy and understand that I may opt out of FactDr subscriptions at any time.